I noticed an interesting comment on this blog while deleting comment spam a few days ago.
1. Jim Mirkalami Says:
February 6th, 2008 at 6:25 pmI have been a frequent visitor of this blog for some time now, so I thought it would be a good idea to leave you with my thanks.
Regards,
Jim Mirkalami
It has that “almost certainly spam but hard to be dead sure” feel to it that a lot of spam comments have. Strangely although it is an optional field, he gives yahoo.com as his website. This seemed even stranger when you note he seems to have his own website (jimmirkalami.com) unless there are two single fathers of two with that name in Ontario.
It seems like a pretty uncommon name, so I google for him. The first few links are news stories alleging questionable ethics in Canadian Auctions for jewelry and Persian rugs. Curiouser and curiouser.
Of course, I am only guessing that it is an uncommon name. It could be the equivalent of Smith in the middle east. It certainly seems fairly popular in among Toronto rug merchants.
Here is my theory.
I’d be upset if the first google result for my (fairly uncommon) name led to a page that started “No charges laid …”.
Knowing a little about SEO and the way google ranks pages, I think you could fairly quickly bury those stories by commenting on a lot of blogs. It would be harder if the story was all over major media. Not many blogs have a pagerank that can compete with CNN or the NYT (pagerank 9), but Google ranks local media about on par with a popular blog. There are no shortage of blogs with a pagerank around 5 or 6. Google only gives canada.com 7.
The comments appear to be somewhat targeted. They seem to appear on blogs (but not always posts) that mention the word ‘auction’ or the word ‘Canada’. There are automated comment spam tools that will find suitable blogs for you, or in a little more time you could do it by hand from any of the blog search engines. A few days later he commented on another post of mine that does contain the word auction (because it is about ebay).
The text of that comment is
Jim Mirkalami Says:
February 8th, 2008 at 3:13 pmI have been visiting this site a lot lately, so i thought it is a good idea to show my appreciation with a comment.
Thanks,
Jim MirkalamiPS: I am a single dad!
Other ones you will see around the place are:
Tammy kingston, on February 5th, 2008 at 5:18 pm Said:
Jim Mirkalami, the very globally highly regarded auctioneer, is a peaceful man single father of two beautiful children. He is also a regular reader of this blog. Great job you ppl!
Aslan, on February 7th, 2008 at 10:06 pm Said:
He is a kind and very loving man.
I don’t know who Tammy is. I get no useful search results for “Tammy Mirkalami”, but I am guessing she is from Kingston (which is near Toronto). I am guessing the Aslan above is more likely to be Aslan Mirkalami (owner of rugman.com) than a lion king from Narnia.
Does this variety of reputation management work? Sure does. A few days later, and at least the top 10 pages of search results for his name are all blogs. The negative press is presumably still indexed, but has dropped way down the list where only a dedicated searcher will find it. He many have overplayed his hand though, as the first result at the moment is a blogger calling him a spammer.
So here are some morals to this story.
- If you are going to have dissatisfied customers, make sure you have few enough that only local media cover the allegations.
- Commenting furiously on blogs will give you Google results that effectively act as noise
- Try to tailor the comments to the blogs a little. It would not take much more time, and would make the effort invisible.
Oh, and surely you already knew that whenever you buy anything (including rugs and jewelery) valuations from the seller are worth only slightly more than the paper your blog is written on.
Luke – congratulations! You called it. You were completely right. Jim’s brother just left me a comment explaining the whole thing and it is precisely what you described in this article.
I’m really not surprised you people aren’t finding much on this guy Mirkalami. It’s hard to find a snake in the grass. Mirkalami is part of a whole family of cousins and brothers who run auctions of questionable ethics all over North America. They use tricks like inflated appraisals, eye candy auction lots like Mercedes, Porsche etc (which are often just rentals), high end watches like Rolex modified with low grade diamonds, Persian and Asian rugs which did not originate from the country they claim and usually have little value, “original” works of art whose authenticity is difficult to confirm, and shills in the crowd to make sure everything goes exactly as planned.
These guys are in and out of town before anyone has a chance to complain. And often people are too embarrassed after having been taken to tell anyone anyway. The auction preview starts just one hour before the auction begins, so you don’t really have time to do any research, and all it takes is a few minutes to fall under the spell cast by the glitter and bling. The fine print is in their catalog, and you don’t get to see that until you surrender your drivers license to the auction. If at this point you feel as though you’re trapped in some sort of web, try not to panic, mr. spider will be along shortly, and all it will cost you is an arm and a leg to get out of there.